EDIT: As long as the first letter in the author's name or title corresponds to the blank slot, it shall be allowed to prevent an unequal amount of books by one author. The most books by one author shall be two titles.
EDIT 2: Bold means read and reviewed.
A. A Siscilian Romance by Ann Radcliff
B. Blue Dahlia by Nora Roberts
E. Emma by Jane Austen
F. Fae by Heather McAlendin
H. Holding Her Breath by Nicole Green
I. The Ice Prince by Sandra Marton
M. Marriane Stephens' Second Sight Dating
N. Nights in Rodanthe by Nicolas Sparks
O. Out of the Rain by Debby Macomber
P. Petals on a River by Kathleen Woodiwiss
R. Romeo, Romeo by Robin Kaye
S. Sweet Love edited by Violet Blue
T. The Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey Niffenegger
W. With this Ring by T.A. Chase